Search This Blog

Showing posts with label Reviews. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Reviews. Show all posts

Wednesday, February 3, 2010

Guest Post!

**We've moved!!**


Please visit our new site, ModernAlternativeMama.com.


Comments on this post have been locked and updates are no longer being made to this page. Please click here to view this article on the new site.


Today I have a guest post on Kitchen Stewardship's site about making over a recipe! Head over there to check it out! I'm very, very excited to be included in such a great blog!

While you're there, check out lots of the other recent posts about making over unhealthy, boxed recipes. Katie is doing that theme right now and she's already made over Hamburger Helper and Salad dressings!


Tonight's regularly scheduled post will still happen at 8!


Like what you read? Subscribe over on the right and get posts everyday in your email!

Friday, November 13, 2009

Movie Review: Expelled: No Intelligence Allowed

**We've moved!!**


Please visit our new site, ModernAlternativeMama.com.


Comments on this post have been locked and updates are no longer being made to this page. Please click here to view this article on the new site.


We recently finished watching Ben Stein's movie, "Expelled: No Intelligence Allowed." The film looked at the question of intelligent design vs. evolution. It was a very interesting experience, and everyone should see it, especially those who believe in ID or creationism.

First, let's define "Intelligent Design" as they do in the movie: The belief that there is some sort of higher power or intelligent designer who created life on earth, which may then have evolved or changed through natural selection and adaptation. That is to say, God is not necessarily that higher power or designer (according to the scientific theory), and they are not saying that once created, life did not change through adaptation. There is absolute scientific credence to this notion -- though evolutionists patently disagree, without actually knowing what the argument is. Most assume that ID is simply religion, but that is not the case.

Stein begins the movie by pointing out how most evolutionary biologists are rather arrogant, referring to ID as "utterly boring" or saying things like "I can't prove a flying spaghetti monster doesn't exist, either." He also shows many scientists who were fired or had their funding cut off for even mentioning that intelligent design MIGHT be a valid theory. As he says, "So much for academic freedom."

At one point in the film, Stein interviews a biologist. "It's a funny thing that questions that aren't properly answered don't go away," he says. When Galileo said that the Earth revolved around the Sun, instead of the other way around, the Catholic church imprisoned him for the last 10 years of his life to keep him quiet (much the opposite of what's going on now). But once everyone saw the evidence for Galileo's theory, they all believed, as we do today. But 150 years after The Origin of Species, despite that we see thousands of the brightest minds rejecting Evolutionary Theory because they don't feel the scientific evidence proves it, most scientists still consider anyone who doesn't believe in evolution a "nutcase." This is despite extreme advances in science since Darwin's time, which allow us to examine the evidence in a totally new and different way. Evolutionary biologists stubbornly cling to evolution based on old, outdated evidence.

Dr. Steve Meyer says, "For every evidence-based argument for Darwin's two points, there is an evidence-based argument against it." This is the view of many, many qualified scientists.

For example, Darwin has no theory on how life originated, where the first cell came from. Generally, it is believed that the big bang occurred, and that the necessary elements for life were put onto earth and the energy stimulated them in just the right way and life occurred. Some think that primordial ooze is also a possibility. Basically, somehow, the correct proteins were in the right place at the right time, and life just came from that (i.e. much like my lego argument before -- lots of non-living proteins were swimming around together and happened to create something complex and new -- life!). Scientists do not know how this happened, but they believe that it did. Several scientists, beginning in the 1950s, even tried to replicate this in the lab. They put all of the proper proteins together and stimulated them with various forms of energy. This type of experiment, which seemed "promising" at first, has NEVER produced any type of life. i.e. this theory CANNOT BE REPLICATED IN A LAB.

When I was watching this segment of the film, I had a thought. Every type of life on the planet reproduces itself either sexually or asexually. Every (non-genetically-modified) species has the ability to reproduce. So, I would like someone to show me one species that can spontaneously produce or come into being, without any part of itself used in reproduction. I'm pretty sure that doesn't happen anywhere on earth. So, why should we accept that it ever did happen?

Another scientist in the movie said that somehow life formed on the back of crystals. When asked how, he stated "I already told you." He could not come up with any greater explanation. So, it remains: scientists do not have any explanation for how life actually formed in the first place. They have various, unproven theories on this, some as strange as "aliens did it" (which, by the way, is actually intelligent design...a superior race of aliens creating us is STILL a designer placing us here).

Some scientists were asked about the proteins theory. There are 250 proteins needed to create life, and many amino acids needed to build each protein. There is "one in a trillion trillion trillion chance this would happen...essentially zero," to quote the movie. Part of the reason that Darwin theorized it did occur is because he had no idea of the complexity of the cell -- he thought it "quite simple." 150 years ago, the cell was considered the building block of life. Darwin had no way of knowing about DNA, amino acids, etc. But today, as one scientist said, "if Darwin thought the cell was a Buick, today we know it is a galaxy." It is that much more complex than Darwin ever knew.

Many of the evolutionary biologists are making this a religion vs. science debate, when it doesn't need to be one. Richard Dawkins, author of The God Delusion says the book is a "full frontal attack on religion," because "both science and religion are trying to explain existence but religion gets it wrong." Dawkins won't entertain anything he thinks even comes close to religious territory, nor will he admit that ID is not a debate about religion (according to the agency that promotes research into ID, it is not a religious theory).

In response, Alistair McGrath wrote The Dawkins Delusion. He says Dawkins is naive and believes that scientific explanation gets rid of religion. In fact, many of the ancient scientists (Galileo among them) were quite religious, and were trying to understand the world that God had created (as they put it). They were not trying to explain God out of the picture, as today's scientists do. Today's scientists say things like "Science tells you there is no God," but this is impossible. God remains metaphysical, and scientists cannot prove His existence either way. To say that science eliminates the possibility of God is wrong and rather idiotic.

One evolutionist says, "Religion...at the level it should be treated. Something fun that people get together and do on the weekends, but that doesn't affect their life as much as it has."

And what would happen to the world if that were the case? If Darwinism were the only theory that explained life?

Two very important historical movements were based on Darwinism. Hitler's Nazi regime, and the eugenics projects in U.S. in the 1920s and '30s. Yes...Nazi Germany was based on Darwinism.

According to Darwin, every species adapts and changes over time as the weaker members die out. Those weaker members do and should die so the "fittest" can survive. Darwin says that "hardly anyone would let his weakest animals breed," and explains it should be the same with people. He says that certain people -- those who are disabled, for example -- are a drain on society and unnecessary. He doesn't go quite as far as to say they should be killed, but Hitler did. Hitler believed in a pure race. He wanted to kill off all of those who were not pure in order to create a better race. Hitler said "What we desire of today's youth is different from what was desired in the past. We must create the new man so that our race will not succumb to the phenomenon of degeneration so typical of modern times." And he used this as an excuse to commit genocide.

Germany wasn't the only country who believed this line of reasoning, however. Plenty of American scientists did (do?) too. Scientists created a field called "eugenics," which aimed to sterilize the "feeble minded" or disabled so they could not reproduce. 50,000 people were involuntarily sterilized. This occurred to "help natural selection along."

This is a total lack of morality. A value is put on each life, so that some are highly valued and some are beyond worthless. Those deemed worthless can be killed. Scarily enough, one of Obama's czars holds this belief today.

Finally, Stein went around to several prominent institutions were scientists had been fired for discussing ID. At one, he was simply escorted out by security. At others, he was told "it had nothing to do with ID" and no real conversation was had. So, Stein ended up speaking to Dawkins. Dawkins has "no idea how life started," he freely admits. He also says, at one point, "it could be that at some earlier time in the universe, some other civilization evolved on some other planet, and they designed a race and put it on earth," and he also admits "if you did research, you might find that there are marks of a designer, from some race of higher intelligence." Yet, Dawkins will not entertain the theory of ID in general. (After the movie came out and Dawkins realized how his comments were being taken and in what context they were being used, he was very upset and stated that he will not even speak to anyone who believes in ID, because it "only gives credence to the theory." How is that for logical scientific debate? He won't even speak to someone who believes differently, he is that arrogant.)

Finally, a small side note...I was criticized in my original post about mentioning the second law of thermodynamics. Yes, it does relate to energy. Here is a more complete explanation of the law:

"The Second Law of Thermodynamics is commonly known as the Law of Increased Entropy. While quantity remains the same (First Law), the quality of matter/energy deteriorates gradually over time. How so? Usable energy is inevitably used for productivity, growth and repair. In the process, usable energy is converted into unusable energy. Thus, usable energy is irretrievably lost in the form of unusable energy."

"Entropy is defined as a measure of unusuable energy within a closed or isolated system (the universe for example). As usable energy decreases and unusuable energy increases, entropy increases. Entropy is also a gauge of randomness or chaos within a closed system. As usable energy is irretrievably lost, disorganization, randomness, and chaos increase."

So as you see, it DOES relate to the point I had. It is unlikely, with the amount of energy required to create life (i.e. to perfectly arrange those 250 proteins into one cell, and continue the process from there to create more and more complex organisms), that such evolution could occur. There would not be enough energy to create those more complex organisms. Instead, as energy was spent, the organisms should fall apart, not become more complex. So, evolution does NOT overcome the Second Law of Thermodynamics.

Have you seen Expelled? Are you interested to watch it now? Do you follow this debate at all? Despite what many have to say, there IS a debate here!

Sunday, November 8, 2009

Movie Review: Sicko

**We've moved!!**


Please visit our new site, ModernAlternativeMama.com.


Comments on this post have been locked and updates are no longer being made to this page. Please click here to view this article on the new site.


Recently, we watched the movie Sicko, by Michael Moore, which originally came out in 2006. The film is about the state of health care in America, and Moore offers the solution of socialized medicine. There is no better time to examine this film than now, when Congress is attempting to make socialized medicine here a reality. Moore makes several claims about the current situation in this country (as well as the situation in other countries which have socialized medicine already) and explains why he believes socialized medicine is the answer.

While Moore makes several good points in the movie, and sets up a story that clearly shows the problems of the American health care system, I believe his solution is completely wrong. The answer to the health care problem isn't "who should pay," but "why is the care we are getting so expensive, and why do we 'need' this type of care?" Nearly everyone in his movie (he features sob story after sob story, and uses very few actual facts) is overweight, suffers from cancer, diabetes, heart disease, etc. Why are all these people sick? One woman is on NINE prescription drugs (unfortunately, this is lower than average; in 2004, the average number of prescription drugs per person in a year was twelve). Why do these people 'require' so many drugs to stay healthy?

Briefly, I'd like to discuss Moore's "documentary" technique. Moore relies on using a series of tragic, personal stories to make his point. He does not look at both sides of the issue, and he does not cite facts. He tells story after story to show examples of his point. It's effective -- many people watching the movie will feel sorry for the people featured, and feel outraged at a government and a health care system that could let these people fall through the cracks. He is more of an artist than a documentarist (is that a word? Spell check says yes). His goal is to evoke an emotional reaction from his audience, for them to feel outrage, which primes them to seek a solution, and therefore to accept the solution that he puts forth: socialized medicine. This is not, of course, how a responsible documentarist would handle the situation.

In the U.S., nearly every story Moore features is of a low-income person, some homeless. Many are minorities and/or immigrants. ALL of these people have HMO health insurance, or none at all. This is a very selective group of the population. There are many people in this country who are not poor, who are not minorities, and who have other health insurance (non-HMO) options. Really, Moore is crucifying the HMO system more than the health care system as a whole, although of course he does not differentiate between HMO and non-HMO systems in his films. Most Americans are already aware that HMOs are not a good option if you can afford anything else.

We, personally, do not have an HMO and have been nothing but satisfied with our insurance coverage. They covered an average of 92% of my first hospital birth (policy says they will cover 80%), and 60% of my home birth (they told us they would not cover it at all). So, clearly, there ARE better options already available.

Another problem is that the "facts" that Moore does state are faulty. For example, he says at the beginning of the movie that "47 million Americans are currently uninsured." This is an often-quoted statistic, but it is false. That number includes illegal aliens (not eligible for insurance, and won't be eligible for socialized medicine, either), those who are eligible for current programs but do not partake (either because they don't choose to or don't know they are eligible), and those who make at least 2.5 times the poverty level and have access to health care, but choose not to purchase it. The real number is more like 5 - 8 million who are truly uninsured. This, however, is not nearly as dramatic.

Moore paints a nice picture of socialized medicine in other countries: people who make plenty of money (he only features people who have money, and who are satisfied with their situation, other than one very brief scene in France where he shows protesters, which makes little sense with the rest of his movie), who have completely free health care, who have lots of vacation and sick time (5 - 8 weeks of vacation in France and unlimited sick days). He says they enjoy a much higher standard of living than we do in the U.S. This, however, is incorrect. It also makes one wonder how such a system is sustainable -- where the government pays for unlimited health care, unlimited sick days, long maternity leaves (up to a year -- which would be nice! -- a topic for another day), and extensive vacation. How can the country be productive? How can their taxes be reasonable? The U.S.'s GDP (per capita) is $47,440. Canada is $38,098. U.K. is $36,358. France is $34,205. So, of these countries -- our GDP (and standard of living, if one defines it by GDP) is the highest.

As for the tax rate, Moore features a family who makes 6000 euros per month, or 72,000 per year. This puts them by far in the highest tax bracket for France (Moore says they are an "average" family -- the highest tax bracket begins around 48,000 euros per year, so they are definitely above average, likely far above). This bracket is taxed 48% of their income, meaning they take home only 52%. That's how they pay for all these nice services.

So, it's looking like socialized medicine isn't really the amazing panacea that Moore sets out to be. It's also, truly, beside the point. I only felt it necessary to get into at all because the politicians in this country are trying desperately to push it through and make it a reality here, and I wanted everyone to be informed why it's NOT a good idea.

That doesn't mean, of course, that our system isn't broken. It is. Moore is correct that politicians are paid a lot of money to back up the drug companies. The drug companies are more concerned with profits than helping people, as are the insurance companies (at least some are). Doctors are concerned with covering themselves so they don't get sued. Profit is the motivator. Drugs are the ONLY answer, so says the FDA. Supplements and other natural medicine is useless.

The way to true health, of course, is to spread mass awareness that drugs and vaccines are NOT the answer. Public health campaigns to teach people to eat less processed food and more fresh produce (NOT GMO or irradiated), and real meats is necessary. People need to learn to get enough sunlight, or take vitamin D supplements. They need to be aware of alternative medicine. They need to know how to balance blood sugar and prevent (or cure) obesity, through proper diet.

This won't happen, because all of these industries -- factory farming, drugs, processed food, etc. -- are controlled by large companies, where money is the bottom line. Sunlight is free. Sustainable agriculture is not big business. There is little money to be made in these areas, as it stands. But, that is the way to true health.

Watch the movie if you're interested. But take it with a grain of salt. If you're reading this blog, you already know the system is broken. Focus on doing YOUR part to fix it by avoiding it as much as possible and trying to keep your family healthy by eating whole, natural foods and using alternative medicine when necessary.

Did you watch Sicko? What did you think? If you are new or have never left a comment, leave one today! I have enabled it so that ALL readers can comment, even without signing in! You can even do so anonymously! Although I'd love it if you left me your first name. :)

Friday, October 30, 2009

Review of Food, Inc.

**We've moved!!**


Please visit our new site, ModernAlternativeMama.com.


Comments on this post have been locked and updates are no longer being made to this page. Please click here to view this article on the new site.



Last weekend, I watched Food, Inc. If you haven't seen it -- I recommend you watch it! You will never think of food the same way again.

I thought I'd share just a few highlights with you here (all facts are as presented in the movie; I have not checked any other sources).

General Information
*The fast food industry pushed factory farming to what it is today, because the restaurants were so popular and needed so much food.
*In 1970, the top 5 beef producers controlled only 25% of the industry. Today, the top 4 control 80%.
*Some organic farms (one is featured in the film) are considered "unsanitary" because their operations are open to the air. Yet, when comparing their naturally raised and processed chickens to factory farmed chickens (which were bathed in chlorine), their chickens had only 133 CFU (bacteria count), while the factory farmed chickens had 3600 CFU (AFTER the chlorine bath!).

Chicken Facts
Chickens have been genetically engineered to grow twice as big in half the time (just 49 days now) and to have large breasts, since most people want to eat white meat. These chickens are too heavy for their delicate bones and could not walk around -- if there were any room to do so anyway. Most chicken houses are completely dark and crowded so the chickens cannot move much anyway.

Corn Facts
100 years ago, farmers could produce only 20 bushels of corn on an acre. Now, they can do 200. The government subsidizes their production so that they can actually produce corn for "below cost." This is because nearly every processed food is a "clever rearrangement of corn." 90% of foods contain some form of corn, including disposable diapers. Farmed fish is also fed corn (yet another reason NOT to eat farmed fish!).

Beef Facts
It is the cattle's corn-fed diet that causes E. Coli to flourish in their guts. A cow fed exclusively grass for only a week before slaughter (and corn-fed prior) will lose up to 80% of the E. Coli in its gut. Today, there are only 13 major slaughterhouses, and cows from all over the country go to each. A single burger can contain meat from thousands of cows. This, plus unclean conditions, allows the E. Coli to get into the meat.

In 1972, 50,000 FDA inspections of slaughterhouses took place. In 2007, only 9,514 inspections occurred. Yet, the rebuttal website claims that the FDA inspects "every cow that is slaughtered," which is impossible with the number of cows that are slaughtered per day!

BPI (Beef Products Inc.) is a large company that makes hamburger filler meat. To ensure "safety," they treat the meat with ammonia. This product is currently found in 70% of the U.S.'s hamburgers, and their goal is 100%.

Monsanto
This company is the most evil. Currently, Michael Taylor (who served as a lawyer for Monsanto, then Deputy Commissioner of FDA, then VP of public policy for Monsanto) is serving as Obama's "Food Safety Czar."

Monsanto is anti-food labeling (i.e. supported not labeling calorie counts, trans fats, GMO foods). They have patented GMO seeds and require farmers to buy new seeds each year. Farmers who save seeds can be and are prosecuted for patent infringement. Monsanto has employees whose only job is to roam farms and find those in non-compliance. Nearly all soybeans grown in this country are Monsanto's GMO soybeans.

There are many, many more scary facts in this movie, but you will have to watch it for yourself! I guarantee you will at least question factory farming after viewing it, if you ever buy anything factory-farmed again! It is eye-opening and really shows why we need to know what we are eating and choose wisely!

Win a FREE bucket of grass-fed beef tallow! Healthy fat, not made by the food industry! The giveaway is being sponsored by U.S. Wellness Meats, and the link will take you to Kelly the Kitchen Kop's site, where you can earn extra entries. Beef tallow is what McDonald's an other fast food restaurants used to fry their fries in...until modern dieticians decided this was "bad." Many people in their 30s and older remember those fries as being the best. Now you can have them at home! It's ironic, isn't it, that the switch to vegetable oils was actually LESS healthy? But if you've read this entire review, and my recent post on fats, you know that what the industry believes and does is not much about health but about being trendy and cheap!